You already sound like there isn't any talking you out on this. You've got your mind made up and all that you need is just the relativism to enable you push through to archive your goals of trading with the whales.

Trading on signals is definitely not the best idea for you and it doesn't look like them whales have got like a group or something information channel for all whales to get there instructions from on how to work the market.
I think they have more like a puppet should you be a part of them group, they make you beleive one thing and they do something else minutes later. That's just being a part of such group can do to you.  

Whales exploit the market, you should know that.