The transactions you are seeing are nothing but selling my Bitcoin to him for USD. I never thought that would make me his alternative account, LOL.
You have nothing else to say except this. Do you live in the same country of 'naim027'? How 'naim027' sent you the USD? Can you show
the proof of your conversation regarding those transactions? Why are you sending BTC to 'naim027' address from the whirlwind.money mixer after the 6th round payment?
I'm not very fond of asking users for private data, but if John Abraham isn't lying, this would be a good start to prove it.
Based on screenshots?
It will be difficult to verify any data, especially if Paypal is involved.
And also if it is based on screenshots. If I recall correctly you said yourself that you can trust screenshots only if you trust the user.
...It's even more baffling that...
He can continue to blah blah blahing but there is a scientific principle very suitable for these cases, Ockam's razor: the simplest explanation is the most likely one.