The banappeals mail you see on the P2Pfinder account is probably no longer valid. Try contacting cryptios via the mail given in this topic. But don't expect a reply, I don't think they has access to a 3 years old report.
The account recovery team is only limited to recover hacked, lost accounts? I hope they are not. They did a great job when I had my account hacked. My position: no ban for HedgeFX. 
It was obvious that the user had no idea how ban thing works or in other thread he would not tell everything openly. At least for the honesty he should not be banned. Although it looks like a clear ban evasion case. We are people, the average people, who make mistakes but as long as we are honest we should get our chances.I vouch your thought too.