To become a good investor first:
1. Patience
2. Ability to understand risk
3. Adopting techniques with careful planning and vetting before taking any action.
4. Always keep portfolio in mind otherwise it is natural to face danger. And don't put all your eggs in one basket.
5. And a skilled investor must know the latest updates about the market.
A prudent investor must adopt these approaches. Because all qualities must be present in an investor otherwise one may face losses.
And also sincerity and setting up trust to your team are some of the things one must do to be a good investor. To be a good investor is not for mere verbal speaking but your actions and activities and dealings towards your clients and you cannot be a good investor when there is nobody recommend you as one.
Because you cannot praise yourself the matter what you are good in it. It is others who sees you doing well will praise you. Your good character of doing things with calm mind is okay to be a good investor.Well I don't know how you are fit to be a good investor with all what you are saying but in my own opinion your investment is actually meant to be a secret dealing and having a strict policy on how you do things will help you out because most investors who had good plans but no strict policy actually end up scattering their investment plans and also their assets so keeping a keen mind is one of the trait of being a good investor. But the whole aspect of sincerity to others and good character of doing things, that part I don't truly understand please enlightenment me more.
An investor must have such integrity. So all the points @Agbe mentions are quite valuable for a P2P trader. But since I will only have Bitcoins to invest in, I also need a good reputation and integrity, so these qualities are definitely needed in an investor. But to be an investor is to invest with a keen mind so that risks, and a plan to do market research, all these things are hidden inside an honest and skilled investor.
I hope you understand....