Re: Secure Element in Hardware Wallets

The image in the OP is probken, @dkbit98 maybe you should switch it to Talkimg.

Quote from: dkbit98 on December 28, 2020, 12:12:23 PM

☵	Name	☵	Open Source	☵	Secure Element	☵	SE Model + Microcontroller	☵	Evaluation Assurance Level	☵
▮	D'CENT	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	NXP P60	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	Safepal S1	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Unknown chip	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	CoolWallet S	▮	NO (soon Y)	▮	YES	▮	NXP P5CD081	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	CoolWallet Pro	▮	NO (soon Y)	▮	YES	▮	NXP J3R110	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	Jubiterwallet	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Infineon ?	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	Kasse HK-1000	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	ST31H320 A03	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	Keevo	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Infineon Optiga Trust-P	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	Secux	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Infineon CC ?	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	Ngrave	▮	N/A	▮	YES	▮	unknown built-in SE + STM32MP157C	▮	EAL7+	▮
▮	Tangem	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Samsung SecureCore microchip ?	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	ImKey	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Military-grade CC security chip ?	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	~~Wookong~~	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	Unknown chip	▮	EAL4+	▮
▮	Hashwallet	▮	N/A	▮	YES	▮	Infineon SLE78	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	Opolo	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	NXP ? + ARM Cortex M4	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	OneKey Classic	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	HSC32I1	▮	EAL6+*/EAL 4+	▮
▮	OneKey Mini	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	ATECC608A	▮	outdated chip	▮
▮	OneKey Touch	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	ATECC608A	▮	outdated chip	▮
▮	HyperMate	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	Infineon ?	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	~~CoboVault~~	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	probably MAX36010-BSN-T	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	KeyStone	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	ARM Cortex-M0	▮	EAL5+	▮
▮	KeyStone3 (Pro)	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	ATECC608B + Maxim DS28S60 (+ Maxim MAX32520)	▮	EAL?	▮
▮	KeyPal	▮	N/A	▮	YES	▮	NXP MCU + ?	▮	N/A	▮
▮	Satochip/Satodime	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	NXP J3H145 and NXP J3R110	▮	EAL6+	▮
▮	Husky HDW20	▮	NO	▮	YES	▮	ATECC608A	▮	outdated chip	▮
▮	Prokey	▮	YES	▮	NO	▮	N/A + STM32F205VG	▮	N/A	▮
▮	Cypherock X1	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	ATECC608A+NXP JCOP3 and ARM Cortex-M	▮	EAL5+ outdated chip 608A	▮
▮	Hito	▮	YES	▮	YES	▮	nRF5340	▮	N/A	▮

Am I the only one here who's bothered by the fact that there's only EAL7 on this whole list, and that most of the mainstream hardware wallets either don't have an SE, or low quality one (hence why I chopped out the first few entries)?

It is quite a shame, as HW manufacturers' reputation is built on trust, and I don't see how you're supposed to gather a lot of trust if you only have one hardware wallet released in the last 5 or so years.