Are you disregarding the fact that the email in the screenshot is actually a valid bitcointalk account email account? This can be easily checked.
At this point, it does not matter whether the email address is valid or not, the screenshot appears to be doctored if you carefully look at it (Please refer to BITCOIN4X's
reply)
And he was also trying to show you that someone can easily alter the details in the screenshot without breaking a sweat.
His pictures weren't at scale. This is an irrelevant comparison by BITCOIN4X tbh.