Electrum is a great alternative as we all know, but at the end of the day, it is also an online wallet, and if you are not using an airgapped device. There will also be certain risks when you use it on an online device frequently. If you have a large amount of bitcoin, I think finding a new hardware wallet is urgent for you. I hope the fact that you once had a broken Trezor wallet makes you lose faith in them. They are electronic devices and sometimes there will be unexpected problems but as long as we still have access to our bitcoins it is not too big of a problem as it is not too expensive to own either.
I plan to use airgapped for a while. Of course, there was a feeling of trauma in using a hardware wallet because my device suddenly died. However, after I explored and got enlightenment about everything that happened to the damaged hardware, I was able to access the private key again and retrieve the assets that I had, which was a bit of a relief, I didn't give up, I also have future plans to buy a new Trezor model. But for now I might choose airgapped first.