Thanks for mentioning, may bhool gya tha iska jawab dena. wesy mai ny yeh mention dekhny ky baad kafi research krny ki koshish ki thi lekin 5 6 videos dekhny ky baad hi mai sure ho gya tha ky future trading haram hai, forex ka to kuch nhi kh skta lekin future to for sure
haram hai, as is my 3 cheezain ati hain. like
- Qabza---- Jo cheez apny qabzy my nhi hai hm uski deal nhi kr skty or yeh cheez hadees sy proof hai, qabzy sy murad ky hm future ky ky jo token ly lety hain (jo ky in reality lety nhi hain) wo hm kisi dosry wallet my transfer nhi kr skrty.
- Interest jo ky kai log kahain ky gy interest nhi hai lekin as jo funding rate hota hai wo short or long krny walo my distribute kiya jata hai or exhcnage wo paisy nhi rkhti.
- Gambling wala factor --- jo ky mai nhi souchta ky ik factor hai bi because gambling means ap speculation kr rhy ho lekin hm sspeculation nhi blky analysis kr ky hedging krty hain to yeh gambing my nhi ati.
Boss ap ik traf ussy Haram kehh rahy ha aur dossry taraf un bato ko ghalat sabit kar rahy haa jiske base pa log future trading ko Haram kehh rahy haa. Second aur third point toh ap ny clear kardiya ky agr hum Kahy ky paiso par intrest laina jaiz Nahi haa toh Jo apko paisa daita haa woh ap sy bilkul interest Nahi laita apny liya un paiso par so yeh baat farigh hogaye yaha.
Third point pa jaisa ap ny Kaha log issy gambling Ki tarah samajty haa aur yeh ussy tarah daikhta bhi haa but haqeeqat Mai yeh gambling Sy completely change ha jistarah ap ny oper Likh liya.
Ab aaty haa first point pa ky jab tak kabza na ho ap Cheez ko sell Nahi karsakty. Iss ky hawaly sy ahadees bhi haa but jaisy Mai NY engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza Ki videos daikhe jis Mai woh keh rahy haa Ky yeh Hadees waha fit aate haa Jaha Dooky ka andaisha ho agr yahi jagah fit kary toh iss Mai ha ky ap ny Cheez ko kabzy Mai laina haa koolna haa check Karna ha taaky doory ko sahi maal ponchy so agr hum dalda oil ka Har dabba ly ussy open kary check kary quality toh woh ap sy open koi ly ga bilkul Nahi.
So agr Dooky ka andaisha ho Jo ky Binance pa bilkul Nahi haa sab geniuen haa toh phir toh yeh kabzy wali baat hi end hogaye toh phir hum kis base pa issy Haram kehh rahy ha