Charting and technical analysis could never been that precise or something that do works most of the time and with that normal behavior and unpredictability of this market then its not really a shocking thing honestly.
At least that's how it works because we rely on mapping and analysis based on predictions and wherever we are the predictions are a reference that is not necessarily true and accurate.
There are really just that people who are really that skeptical about these TA results without even trying to look at on whats its relevance in regarding about trading. Yes, it cant be precise but doesnt mean that it would really be useless because sooner or later you would be able to find out that you would really be needing up these things just for you to have atleast on having some ideas on what you would really be gonna dealing with. You cant really just rely with news like forever because we know that events and happenings doesnt really come often or happen all the time.
This is why you would really be needing to have that skills and awareness on how to make use or able to plot some charts.
Relying on other people's predictions without own analytical knowledge is not appropriate to engage in trading because we cannot completely rely on other people's predictions. Some of the considerations may be other people's predictions as reference material, but it is much more important to have your own analysis because it is a strength for us to be confident in getting involved in trading. Skepticism is a lack of knowledge so that people are unable to do something correctly and accurately.
I agree that our presence in trading must be knowledgeable because we cannot rely on other people's analysis to take much bigger risks. If not then trading is not the right choice for someone to get involved further.