If satoshi decides to sell his coins OTC to someone giving him his private keys will those coins have a premium ?
Nah,
We have had old Satoshi era addresses waking up and transferring their coins, some probably to exchanges no one has talked about or cited any premium attachment to those joins. Bitcoin mined in 2010 is the same as bitcoin mined in 2024 in price. The market dictated the price.
The only people I see going crazy over these are the ordinals' brigade because they know they will sell hot air to the noobs for abnormal profits.
It's a moot question, but if Satoshi did want to sell his coins or even just the private keys I think they would sell at a premium. I'm sure Craig Wright would love to get his hands on them as that would go a long way to furthering his scam if he could sign a message or send funds from one of them.