You threw out a lot of smart ideas, and then your last sentence 1BTC=1BTC makes no sense (even though a lot of people say some variation of that in order to attempt to mean something like only BTC matters, which is surely a known logical fallacy even though peeps still get pleasures out of saying that).
It may not make much sense, true but the stability is unparalleled.
Beyond that, I think people are looking for something that doesn't really exist in more than a transitory and ephemeral manner.