I've had a few various wallets over the years, but was wondering what the consensus is currently?
If you have been already in Bitcoin community for years, used some different wallets, I believe you already well known about basics criteria to choose a good Bitcoin wallet to use.
Non custodial: you own private keys.
Open source: reproducible, can be tested by community, to detect back doors from wallet developers.
Other things like Lightning Network support for example, comes after first two criteria.
https://bitcoin.org/en/choose-your-wallethttps://walletscrutiny.com/