In rating coaches like Nagelsmann and Tuchel, consider their track records and current state. While Tuchel has a history of trophy wins, his time at Munich this season has been challenging. Nagelsman's success at the club before being sacked shows positive managerial abilities. Judging their abilities solely on one season's performance will not be fair. Tuchel's past glories shouldn't be ignored, but Nagelsman's potential and achievements should be acknowledged too.
Maybe i am late but i was quite surprised by read the article. Is it true that Kompany is the new coach replacing Tuchel? Even I was surprised and just found out about this. Is he worth it? so far he has no serious achievements, even with Burnley he failed. Burnley relegated to the Championsip. I am confused by Munich's decision, are they frustrated? Even Kompany has only been a coach for 4 years. If I were the owner of Munich, I would prefer Tuchel to stay in Munich. But let's see with a 3-year contract what he can do, maybe Kompany can make a surprise. LOL
Source:
https://www.bundesliga.com/en/bundesliga/news/bayern-muich-unveil-vincent-kompany-new-coach-press-conference-live-27630