You just said Komapny is not an experienced player, and that is the reason why many are saying different things about the manager. People are judging him based on his last performance at Burnley; even though he promoted Burnley to the Premiership, they got relegated, and that is why many people are sceptical about him managing Bayern Munich. Although I know that Bayern Munich will have their own personal reasons for bringing him to the club as a coach, based on how people view it, people still think his experience is not enough to bring Bayern Munich back to their performance like before anytime soon.
One of the reasons why the club management chose Kompany was because Munich had no other choice. There were several coaches who were given contracts by Munich but unfortunately they did not accept them. I even read an article that said that they once offered a contract to Xabi Alonso, but Alonso chose to stay at Leverkusen. I'm not underestimating Kompany but tbh Kompany wasn't their first choice. Munich is a big club and many doubt Kompany's abilities. I think Kompany should be given the opportunity to prove that he deserves to be Munich manager.
Opportunity has been given, we are just awaiting to see what he can do for the club as the clubs new manager. I also heard of the time Xabi Alonso was given an offer to coach Bayern Munich before the end of the last season, but it was all rumor at that time and at the end a news came out that he was going to stay at Bayern Leverkusen and spend more season with the team. The choice of Kompany came as a big shock to us and I never imagined he’ll get to coach such a big club after he has been relegated with Burnley when he was their manager last season.
The difference is clear enough, if you can’t manage a lower team and make them finish above relegation zone, no one will believe that you can do something different when managing a bigger team and that’s why a lot of speculations are going around that, Kompany cannot manage the team and the task given to him is too big for the him to handle. I just want to believe that Komoany can do great thing in the club. Low experienced managers are able to manage teams from their scratch to big teams today, so I will also take Kompamy’s case as an example and hope that he’ll perform very well to be applauded for his efforts at the end of the season.