This is now becoming a debating thread.
This thread supposed to be a similar thread like AI reporting thread if I am not wrong. All I wanted to see a signed message from an old address from that guy and he did it. Now, if you still have doubts, you may leave a neutral which JollyGood did. But you should have a point why you are leaving that.

OP, if you disagree with the feedback, create your own reputation thread and invite JollyGood to join if he wants (You seems created a thread, but it's locked). If other community members think he is not right and overreacting, he might get some DT exclusion. But if community thinks he is right, you are likely to get more feedbacks.