[For me, if I had to choose the "stupidest thread", (and let me be very clear, I don't see any 'stupid threads' on this site), it would not be this thread or that one but the Wall Observer thread. Would it not make more sense to yelp about that one? I mean, it even went to the point where administrators disabled signatures on that thread.
This is all just pointless bickering.
Opinion divided. As some people said already that the lists is worthless and belongs to off-topic, some people are supporting it. Although if we should see it very well, the post does not fall under what we can called Bitcoin speculation because the thread is not about speculating bitcoin price. But as you see reputed people give OP merit so many more people gave OgNasty merit. Even a staff is among that gave him merit. OP should know that opinion of people would be different about this and nothing will be changed. But if it is a newbie that posted that topic, it would be moved to off-topic asap.