Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Discussion
Merits 2 from 1 user
Re: Can the Bitcoin Core developers make crucial changes?
by
franky1
on 18/10/2024, 08:39:47 UTC
⭐ Merited by ABCbits (2)
contributors make REQUESTS but the maintainers do the merging of those requests or reject them. and yes the maintainers can force merge their own code without anyone else. in short it needs the maintainers to decide. they govern bitcoin code

most contributors are not helping with code, but instead just spell checkers or translators. when you look at whom helms the code changes of the big features you see the same short list of names that do the real coding

in short contributors do not have the same power, access, privilege or rank of control as the maintainers
..
as for if another brand of a full node has equal chance of making a protocol change vs how easily core changing the protocol is just accepted without any notice/conflict/consent. well in recent years core have taken control and other brands of nodes if changing the protocol are treated as altcoin proposals, not bitcoin proposals. everything these days needs to go through the core maintainers governance to change bitcoins protocol

Sounds like bitcoin is kinda centralized to a handfull of maintainers who hold the keys. What happens if they all die in a car crash or become dictators?

then the core brand dies and people then rush to create a new github and fight to win trust of a new group of devs that were not in a car crash

however the maintainers of core dont live in the same house and dont carpool to the same office together (unless they were at a convention/conference they all turned up to, that offered a minibus transport they all got on) so odds are if one died the other maintainers choose a replacement and just revoke privileges of the deceased one, and core continues governing the protocol