Interesting concept, they would finally get a chance to do something good for a change 
Unless they were the ones who wrote those shitposts with their alts in the first place. 
I don't think most of the members care about badges in their profiles
I think its quite the opposite considering how many times this topic (badges for reporters) came up since I've been on the forum. Those who spend a lot of time on forum tend to start taking it way too serously so even something as trivial as a reporter badge starts to look important.