Post
Topic
Board Hardware wallets
Re: Onekey Classic or Bitbox
by
Pmalek
on 05/12/2024, 10:04:37 UTC
See https://walletscrutiny.com/hardware/onekey/   and  https://github.com/OneKeyHQ/firmware/releases (I have check the hash of classic.3.9.0-Stable-0805-f3b0717.signed.bin)
The latest version of classic/v3.9.0 (Aug 12, 2024) still not passed through WalletScrutiny's testing.   
Why can a hardware wallet that has never passed walletscrutiny testing be called an open-source wallet?
Wallet Scrutiny last tested OneKey classic 2 months ago, and it passed all the tests except the last one. The binary they built from source doesn't match the published source code. Some other wallets fail on this step as well. For instance, Blue Wallet has done that several times. I don't have the competence to explain that, but I can see that there was some discussion about it between the Wallet Scrutiny team and OneKey on GitHub. I leave it to other people to comment on and interpret what the reasons are for failing the final test and if what OneKey said makes sense.

Besides Wallet Scrutiny, there are other researchers who test crypto wallet and perhaps it passed all their testing...