yet we don't live in a communist country which is strange if you think about it the other states that do this are all under a communist type dictatorship they demand without giving anything in return
What's your point? I don't think we have much States left in India under communist rule anymore! I believe it's only Kerala now which contributes around 4% to India's GDP. what are trying to prove by saying they only demand without providing anything?
Communism in China is very different than communism in India. I am sure you don't know otherwise you wouldn't have mentioned about dictatorship!