Overall, what are the general views within the community on this matter?
I think you are harassing said member with your, "respond to the accusations or I will keep my feedback" he doesn't owe you any explanations, you don't have any proof about the accusation, your tag is unjustified.
Man, doesn't this seem a little twisted on your part? It's okay if you don't respond to every accusation against you, but it's a mistake if someone else ignores such things.
I am interested in knowing what
kind of privlage JollyGood has that other members don't.

I hope you don't mind using your post as the reference of the warning I have for other members especially low rank and less powerful members.
JollyGood is nobody but an Instigator, propagandist, conspiracist, deceiver, contrarian, know-it-all, the last but not the least - a narcissistic. Low rank and less powerful members are advised to stay away from him.