What does "Proxied" do in Cloudflare? I currently can't access the URL, while the IP shows Apache's default page. I think you should turn that off.
"Proxied" makes this address pass through the Cloudflare server to reach the website visitor. If you disable this, this address goes directly to the visitor without going through Cloudflare's servers. Basically, disabling this is the same as not having Cloudflare.
Maybe in this case, this is not necessary.