Yeah I do get where you concept is coming from but still there is something very interesting you need to understand and that's the fact that both Bitcointalk and Altcoins talks are totally different and  distinct forums and it isn't really nice to want to try making them adopt some things that make them different from each other.

Basically Bitcointalk is a very simple forum with just around 7 ranks ranging from newbie to administrator compared to Altcoins talks that has numerous ranks. The whole stuff is quite similar to how most teleported members wanted the karma system over there like the merit system here but it didn't seem to cut it.

Nevertheless I bet Loyce V will add your suggestion to the next April fools event