[edited out]
Nobody is saying that when you buy bitcoin at the dip, it wouldn't give your a bigger profit compared from when you buy higher. But the problem lies in your waiting for the dip without buying any bitcoin. Waiting is very dangerous and it's a success stealer which makes it not a good accumulation practice for new investors and low coiners.
If you want to start using profits to make decisions on which strategy to use, you will feel buying at the dip is the best but it isn't, because in the long run it is the quantity of bitcoin in your portfolio that will determine your profits. Someone with 3btc will be in more profits than someone with 1btc.
It seems that we have given several of these kinds of examples in the past in which some guys are more whimpy than others, since some guys are overly preoccupied with his cost per BTC rather than consistently, persistently and perhaps aggressively buying bitcoin, so yeah, there may well be guys who end up with way more bitcoin, and sure their cost per BTC are higher, yet we likely would rather be the guy with more bitcoin rather than the guy with less bitcoin and lower costs per BTC.
The longer the timeline the likely greater the variance, but yeah, in the short-term some guys are going to act like they are geniuses based on their whimpy approach towards buying bitcoin, and sure they end up with lower costs per bitcoin, but perhaps they also end up with way lower quantities to bitcoin, too.
Don't get me wrong.
I am not even obsessed with having to have a lot of bitcoin, yet there is quite a bit of comfort that comes from having our bitcoin investment work for us once we get it to a certain size in which we have more than enough bitcoin.
I love this point of yours.. Ever since I was young and have understood what money is all about, that you must work and invest in order to become balanced in life. I have always thought of which investment that I will put my funds into and allow it work for me instead of having people to work for me or work for someone till retirement without having something that you can rely on.
This was why when I learned about bitcoin and checked past history, I started taking my bitcoin accumulation journey very serious with consistent and persistent to keep my investment ongoing. I buy aggressively when I can and if I am opportune, I also buy at the dip. Infact, I have plans to keep on increasing my DCA buying overtime based on increasing my financial strength so that my dreams will come to pass in future when the size of my bitcoin portfolio will continue generating more profits for me due to its compounding value.