I think Amorim deserves more time and it's too early to judge because Erik Ten Hag really destroyed Manchester United.
Unfortunately the trophies he won made people ignore the fact that he is not a hood coach, check I European and Epl stat, they are poor. The quality of players he got and the kind of impact he had on them, Christiano Ronaldo was right about the team mentality thanks to him. He was mod and didn't want to become better rather just settled for less.
Amorim got a huge job and I know he would have expected the task to be tough but not this tough which is the issue, let's see if he can turn things around with time.
Yeah, Eric Ten Hang really didn't handle the situation of Manchester United players properly especially that of Ronaldo. It was as if he came to the club to be a disciplinarian instead of being a coach that he was appointed for. I believe he did what he did to Ronaldo to instill fear on the other player, they would be like, 'if he can do this to a whole Ronaldo, then who are we'. With the money he spent, he was supposed to have performed better than what he did.
Unfortunately that plan that didn't work because he had issues with other players after him, with the likes of Sancho and Rashford.
His disciplinary methodology didn't work and to be honest I didn't expect it to work. They are players, you can't just instill fear on them all in just manner. Anyway his winning or competitive mentality is too poor for them to succeed, just a domestic trophy like FA Cup and Carabao cup and he thought he won it all simply because of Manchester United trophy drought.
And frankly speaking, that method can never work. There are certain players who has built there names over the years and this took them a lot of time to build, you can't just come one day and be dishing out orders as if they are your children without even considering their own part. I'm very sure in one way or the other all big name players have egos and I think that's factual. He should have looked for a better way to handle such a situation, that same player you talk bad of was coached by great manners in the past and they had no issues like the one of Ten Hang with him.