There are ways to calculate out formulas which would show that if a guy sells 50% of his BTC every time the BTC price doubles, then such guy would never experience compounding value in his profits because he would be cashing out all of his profits and merely maintaining his bitcoin investment size at the same amount that he put into it.
A guy who were to cash out 25% of the value every time that the BTC price doubles would be cashing out half of the profits and allowing the other half to compound upon itself.
Surely my choices to cash out up to 10% the value of bitcoin every time it doubled and then later going down to such values of cashing out only 3% every time it doubles, these cashing out amounts are still allowing 80% to 94% of the profits to continue to compound upon itself, and since my bitcoin holdings had gone through more than 8 doublings (
see my compounding value discussion) from the time that the BTC price was $250 in 2015, so therefore an overwhelming amount of that value had been allowed to continue to compound upon itself at least 8 times so far, even though some of the amount was withdrawn out of the holdings... which I also claim to be serving as downside insurance, too.
Cashing out 50% or 25% of our Bitcoin investment anytime the price of Bitcoin appreciate is not a nice strategy most especially for low coiners and investors that haven't gotten to over accumulation stage because their portfolio won't look good even though they are taking profit because the investment will be in a stagnation point somehow. But for those investors who have accumulated enough and somehow feel they have gotten to there over accumulation stage someone JJG can decide to sell when the price of Bitcoin double or appreciate but I'm sure JJG can not sell 50% or 25 % of his investment even though he has enough Bitcoin because he is still somehow targeting or planning to have more Bitcoin in his portfolio because of what Bitcoin holds in the future.
Moreover, cashing out our Bitcoin investment even 10% or 3% is not suppose to be an option for a low coiner or an investor that doesn't have much Bitcoin in his portfolio rather there focus should be on how to accelerate there investment to a point they will now feel that yes, they have really accumulated enough and so they can play around with there investment if they want to.
I agree with you that it is not a good idea for low coiners to take out profits whenever Bitcoin appreciates because that will never allow them to accumulate enough Bitcoins. However, if I understand correctly, I don't think JayJuanGee is encouraging any investor to sell 50% or 25% of their Bitcoin investment when the price appreciates.
JayJuanGee is simply trying to explain that if an investor sells 50% of their Bitcoin whenever their investment doubles, they might be able to make a good profit compared to someone who cashes out 25% whenever their investment doubles. Similarly, the person who always cashes out 25% cannot compare to someone who only takes 10% when their Bitcoin investment doubles.
JayJuanGee is explaining that if an investor avoids cashing out a large percentage of their Bitcoin investment, their remaining investment will continue to grow and bring them more profit. The profits that the investor leaves untouched will generate even more profits. On the other hand, an investor who cashes out 50% of their Bitcoin investment whenever it doubles will not see as much growth. Taking smaller percentages of profit whenever the investment doubles allows for greater increases in profit over time.