How many times has this worked for you? That's another important thing you should have added, one or two tries isn't enough to know that if it actually works.
This is the question I wanted to ask the author: how many times did they use it? Once, twice, or even three times is not enough. You have to try it repeatedly, for ten to fifteen times, to know if it accuracy. You have to stick to whatever analysis it gave you, without including your own, to ensure you didn't tamper with the results.
The AI gave you results; you can't be certain so you have to redo it again and again and bring out a detailed analysis with results for us to have a better understanding of your experiment.
I do believe that AI can assist a lot because, as long as information about the teams and their games is on the internet, the AI can actually search it out and draw an analysis conclusion. So, yes they can assist, but it has to be tested over time to be certain.