Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: Can Quantum Computers capable for guessing BIP39 Seed Phrases?
by
Orange89
on 13/05/2025, 05:45:29 UTC
You know I have been reading about these Quantum Computers with their super Power and impact on the cryptography
That get me thinking about the Security Of Wallet especially with BIP39 seed phrases one
What I understand that BIP39 seeed phrases are generated Using the strong entropy and protected by modern cryptography algo
But I am Wondering

Will a Powerful Quantum I MEAN a really powerful quantum computer
Can it able to guess Or somehow brute force a BIP39 SEED PHRASE

Feel Free to share what do you think and also in future can it do it
Like If We Train Specific AI MODEL to guess these Seed Phrase

No quantum pc's are not the method needed to crack sha-256

Think of a magic lucky charm that gives you the luck to pick a seed from the set of seeds available.


Magic can do it.

Or a better way to say this  is no known  method of math can do it fast enough so the method would appear magical in its nature.


here look at this seed generator


https://getcoinplate.com/bip39-seed-phrase-mnemonics-generator-offline-online-tool/?srsltid=AfmBOor9jwmrMV_eRThVvlpWcYR8D4COLHDVU_6gtSqi0e0UauJttNNB&v=0b3b97fa6688

it picked the following seed below:



wild
calm
unable
luxury
nature
weasel
spy
garlic
curious
glove
bottom
educate
mind
pear
coil
trap
sound
must
work
shoot
dice
tragic
current
volume


if I had unreal good  luck the seed above would work in the first wallet I try it on.

if I did this time after time it would be better than unreal good luck it would be magical luck


It is just as likely that the paragraph above becomes true as quantum crack sha-256 in under 100 years


So as I said you need luck of such quality it needs to be magical.

or it certainly would appear to be magical.

and if you show it around you will be whacked.

Yes I think I don't have the good Luck today Mate Grin
From Morning with your generator I generated about 50 phrased just for the curiosity
and then I check their RECORD HISTORY and what I observed that's there is not even a single Transaction on these wallet
And somehow at a time I get the same Phrase again at that site

So maybe there is some hard-coded value of phrase in that website that's generating randomly according to my observation

You are correct , somehow I wonder how they generated so perfectly
that even no one can guess them - that's like a seriously wow in term of security all these public key private asymmetric is really fascinating I must say