I don't agree with the part I've bolded, because I believe an answer from an AI will always have a soulless feel to it and a certain pattern, be it the wording, the structure, or the use of punctuation, that makes it different from a human answer.
In other words, you don't believe it because you have an immovable preconception that you won't let reality change.
When you find out that there are people who
instead of going to a psychologist use ChatGPT or that
AI today diagnoses better than doctors, you might have a heart attack.
On the other hand, if when you speak of “soul” you mean it in a religious sense I respect your beliefs but I think our basic ideas are too different to enter into debate.