From what I know or if you look at their posting history, bitcoingirl.club takes some breaks and doesn't post for a number of days so it's very likely that the just off for a couple of days. We will have a clear picture once the last active time is visible after a few days.
You used your time to find the truth. Unfortunately Vod does not have this simple intellectual brain to look at the post history and figure out something real. You are absolutely correct in your observation.
I wonder if it's safe to unlock a thread where he has shown he will not respect the rules.
Respect is a mutual agreement that needs to earn. You can not force or buy it.