Honestly, I've just been using Metamask for a long time now, not because I was a fan but because it just worked lol. I've seen recommendations about rabby.io, but I need to look into it more. Basically said to be with smoother UX and with added security features.
I've also used metamask previously but I've only needed to use it once within that past 3-4 years now, so not sure how reputable they still are. Them and trust wallet are the only ones I recognize on the list, I'm certainly not a fan of the latter, so I'll be sticking to metamask.
I got confused for a second with the handles and them not being verified at the time. This probably is X doing some checks due to changes in the accounts.