Yeah a bit surprised to see Celtic knocked out even though they are one of the familiar teams in the Champions League, this is not just luck but clearly we are seeing a decline in performance from Celtic.
Yes, it's true that Celtic's attacking players have truly declined, consistently failing to convert every good chance they had.
I observed that in the first and second legs, Celtic consistently dominated the match, repeatedly attacking Kairat's defense, but it was ridiculous that they couldn't score.
Kairat also seemed fortunate to escape the penalty shootout, but Kairat relied solely on defense in the first and second legs, allowing them to create chances in the penalty shootout.