Of course, you need to follow your instinct. I don't think that Atletico will be able to bounce back in this match because Villarreal ia super hot. If you have watched their matches this season, you will understand what I mean. The coach needs to work his on men and bring back the vibes that they were on last season.
Last season Atletico did fairly we only that they still do not have that quality in their depth, they still struggle to give the team that form that will position them strategically for a wey contending chance, the kind of strength they are know for much earlier was such that would not make Villarreal a problem to them of which I do not think really is at this point except for the few times they are not in their best shape and form but the coach also got some assignments to do if the team must get back solid.