If you guys turn out to be right, then believe me, it will be through pure chance. If I am right, it will be because I know I am right beforehand to the best of my abilities.
So the best they can do is being fortuitously right while you'll always be, at worst, intelligently wrong. Bravo. Schopenhauer would be proud.
May I suggest some light reading for you, Mat?
What if - and I'm stretching here - the universe is not actually Mat-centric? What if he is just another tiny hole in the gravitational field? I know it sounds ridiculous, but what if somebody else is also right?
Mat, please entertain such possibility.