Ok so basically each user will have to validated by an Admin and the newbies will have their own section where they can post until they reach 5 posts. Sounds good?
Sounds terrible. Like a private members club.
If they want to moderate their own website's forum that seems fine to me - As long as freedom of speech is maintained here. This is will continue to be the main port of call for both positive and negative statements about the coin, as it should be.
You cannot simply prevent others from speaking their mind on a coin just because it harms your vested interest (e.g. you are holding coins you are trying to hype up and sell for a higher price and someone is making that harder for you to do by speaking negatively).
As long as this thread is a free speech zone the separate forum is no big deal. Anyone will be able to clearly see that its members will obviously be firmly attached to the coin and will take what they say with a grain of salt.
The new forum will be designed to listen to legitmate concerns and answer them. I will only moderate spam/fud. The users that get banned will be chosen by the community through the karma system unless it turns out that their questions where legitimate.
From here I only have deleted fud/spam.