.............
Any advice on if BitJohn, mullick, and all of cryptsy support stops responding about this issue? Did cryptsy effectively just lose my coins forever and I'm just SoL? That's how it feels.
I wonder the same thing....

Yes, so do I.
That is not professional how cryptsy is acting this PHS problem. No response, no Excuse, no nothing...we all want to know what happened to the coins from the first 2 weeks of may?