So either way, you still lose. As others like to say, there is no such thing as a free lunch.
With fixed supply, compound growth in the economy translates to compound growth in the value of the currency. To maintain the value of the subsidy as a constant, it must decline as the economy grows, and increase as the economy shrinks.
A fixed subsidy will increase in value with economic growth, but decline as a portion of the economy, over time. For example, in Monero, there will be about 18mm xmr circulating when subsidy is fixed at ~250k/an, according to the last proposal from core. The first year that's ca1.4% VAT. After 10 years it's ca. 1.2% VAT.
Whether the network is viable will depend on whether the tax is high enough to prevent growth/competitiveness, or low enough to prevent adequate funding of security. If mining goes to PoS the cost tends to zero.