Post
Topic
Board Altcoin Discussion
Re: Why Poloniex Has Rejected SuperCoin
by
provenceday
on 15/06/2014, 01:05:07 UTC
can i aks my BTC donation back in the Hacker event?

 Grin
busoni you are a honest guy, i like you.

hope you can handle this tough thing correctly.

thanks


Cheesy You actually can, I don't hold people to that.

It is pertinent that the coin was hard forked to change the maximum supply. We have not examined all the changes made, but this may strengthen the case for the MAX_MONEY issue being negligence rather than laying the foundation for a nefarious plan. Nevertheless, the variable could have been deliberately left unchanged for the same reasons, and in any case, it indicates sloppy coding that opens the coin up to, for example, a much larger double spend attack. We're going to look into this further, but an apology may be in order for not coming to dev privately first.

There is also the issue of the anon implementation proposed, which even by the dev's admission is highly vulnerable to "cheating." I would never list a coin that relied on the honesty of people operating a mixing pool. It would be trivial for them to steal coins and impossible to prove that they had done so.

I don't agree with you, these parameters are simply irrelevent. We did not miss them, we simply think there's no need. We welcome anyone to review our code, and we are happy to discuss with anyone. But blunders like this are not agreed. Your ignorance simply caused a lot unnecessary confusion. Should you contact us, we would have explained all to you.


oh dev, you are online now!

be patient, busoni is a very honest and respectable guy, i know him.

but it seems he has some misunderstanding on Supercoin coin.
it is understandable, everybody will make a mistake .
also it seems supercoin dev also make some mistake on the ANN thread.

thanks