Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: [ANN] [FRESH] Bitcoin fork "No Forced TX Fee" v0.5.2 & 0.6.0rc1 released
by
ShadowOfHarbringer
on 12/02/2012, 23:56:22 UTC
Ah.

What you're having happen there is that when you send your transaction is dropped by the network— lacking the required fees because it looks like a DOS attack (fast turnaround)—, but after every block that doesn't contain your transaction the client tries retransmitting it (with a random delay).  After two hours or so, the input coins have matured enough that they no longer require a fee.  After that when your client resends then it goes through.

If you'd just waited the same time it would have sent without a fee in mainline.  From a usability perspective, when the times are reasonably short, it might be better to wait like that... but if you shut down right after sending the transaction will be stuck until you start back up and wait an hour or so, and a lot of people do that.

You are absolutely right, however still missing the point.

It is my risk to take and whether i still want to gamble and send the coins should be my decision.
This is why i bugged mainline devs multiple times for a simple configuration setting or a simple "are you sure" dialog, or both.

They are acting like the issue doesn't exist at all. Why is a simple configuration setting such a problem ? Open source is all about choice.