OP: The scammer tag is to give users an idea of whether or not you can be trusted based on your past behavior. I think you should have a pretty clear answer as to whether it should stay now.
Sorry, I think your definition is false. It is merely an indicator of whether or not you should exercise additional caution.
The idea is to warn people who might trade with him, not to punish him. The forum doesn't handle justice.
Wow. You can't have missed his point more completely. Just because it's not meant as a punishment doesn't mean it's not used to judge whether or not you can be trusted. That's exactly what it's for, and your answers are saying more than anyone else could.