I think this should be your aim with this punk:
1. Steals coins.
2. Has a nightmare time and bad dreams.
3. Returns coins, incurring cost that leaves him out of pocket.
4. Lesson learned.
Give him 10% and step 4 is not going to happen.
100% agree with this. The hooligan stole kLee's property. While I understand the desire to end the shenanigans and recover most of the property as quickly as possible, what kind of message would it send to others to
reward the looter with 10%?
Ultimately, it's kLee's decision, and I do wish him the best.