Thanks guys. When I changed one to DCHP I thought I wouldn't have issues with the 2nd. After crashing my internet for a few hours, being unable to connect to the first S3 to boot I started from square 1...or maybe 2 since I didn't do a full reset on the 1st miner.
I unhooked miner #2 after doing a factory reset on it. I figured I better make sure this baby is clean.
Then I went back to miner #1 and changed back to Static IP address. I changed the IP address to 98 from 99. Then I plugged #2 back in and used the .99 address. I switched everything back to DCHP, found the addresses and basically just followed the guide.
They are both humming away happily while everyone in my living sweats like pigs

It took a total of about 10 hours and a lot of heart ache to get these going but when you finally do, at least from my hobbyist perspective, it feels nice.