Occasionally he is right about small, short term movements
As far as I can tell, he gets the big ones right in the ways that count, and sizes appropriately to optimize the expectation. The small short-term ones, not so much. I think my monkey does better in fact. To be fair I don't think he generally cares about the small short-term ones.
Perhaps someone with more time than I have can go through kireinaha's posts and back-test them?
his analyse style ( not drawing dumb lines on charts, actually looking into the details compiling data to get info, trying hard to paint an accurate picture of the market ) does not lend itself to the short term.