Ok, so that covers the "stolen gift card" aspect. Now how do you explain him paying other people's debt, handing out btc to people in hardships, or kickstarting a fund with btc that otherwise wouldn't have happened? None of these that I mentioned involved any gift cards that could be potentially stolen like you mentioned. First time I saw him paying someone's debt out of the blue, my jaw just dropped, as I was pretty confused. But then I saw this several more times and figured he was more than generous to help someone out. Are you going to say these are stolen btc too?
Perhaps the people that donate to charity in real life, maybe all these funds are illicit too, right?
The total value of gift cards he's given out is a HELL of a lot more than the total value of these LTC giveaways, handouts and debt repayments he's done. I never said those giveaways/repayments were illicit, they were obviously OK, but I don't believe his story that he's paying for all these gift cards at full price and I suspect something illegal is going on to obtain them which is reasonable considering how common carded gift cards are. Maybe he's just a rich carder/troll but who knows really all we can do is speculate, but you can bet I won't be getting any of those gift cards and people need to be careful.
I'd feel a lot less suspicious if he gave a reasonable explanation as to how he's obtained so many gift cards from many different websites, but thus far he hasn't he just claims he buys them for cash at full price and is giving them away for a fraction of the cost.
How do you know? I don't see any loss on the buyer side as they either pay wayyyy below the market price for each of the gift card and he even have some of them for free. So far, no one have reported a single problem out of a lot of buyers. I believe the gift card he gave is lesser than the total amount he gave out in those coins. I personally have received more than $100 of the coins out of the blue. I can see that he have given out more than that amount of individual users and the community. If he starts scamming people, the person would most probably report it and people would spam him negative trust and stop buying from him. It only take one trade $5-10 to ruin a $1000++ perfect trade history.