You do realise that the discussion going on in this thread has been discussed over and over and over for thousands of years?
No closer to any scrap of evidence or proof than we was 1000 years ago, and no further from any scrap of evidence or proof than we will be 1000 years from now.
This applies to both sides of the argument.You do realise that don't you?
I will realize it if you realize these facts, and all the others already referenced:
1) that we can and should no longer wish away expansive phenomena of this type.
2) The psychical origin of the Seth material does not automatically invalidate its claims
3)
"Nothing is more likely to impede investigation than premature acceptance of 'explanations'"4) personalities continue to exist after physical death