This proves absolutely nothing at all.
But guys, PLEASE, remember to exercise caution with "too good to be true" deals. While BPB's case really is true, it's very atypical, and people should exercise caution and do their research before making a decision when trading on similar "too good to be true" deals.
pirateat80 was "really true" too... until it wasn't.
Where's the proof he isn't:
1) Scamming people with different nicks, to pay for those gift cards
2) Being paid off by scammers who take advantage of those he predisposes to making foolish decisions
Even if he isn't doing any of those things, he's de facto teaching people to make foolish decisions and become scammer bait.
IMO that makes him at least partly at fault for scams resulting, whether he was directly involved or not.I agree with this. He very well possibly purposefully got himself banned, would create a new account that does something very similar to what he was doing, but at a much lower discount, then pulls off a scam.