So, will those of us who don't have our own copy of stats get a back pay?

Can I trust the stats on the dashboard? Because, it doesn't seem so. Currently it says I have 40.4M valid shares this round (and no pending payout). At 0.000000000911 per share that should be about 36 mBTC (w/o any bonus). But I've only been paid about 25 mBTC since the last block was found.