I thought the S1 had the same efficiency as the S2?

I think that graph might be misleading?
Here are real efficiency numbers at the wall:
S1 : ~2 W/GH
S2 : ~1.05 W/GH
S3 : ~.78 W/GH
S4 : ~.69 W/GH
I can personally confirm S1, S2, and S3 efficiency numbers using a decent gold power supply and kilowatt to measure power usage at the wall, but am using Bitmains published info for S4 efficiency.