Look forward to seeing the results

And here they are:

My DOA/Reject rate instantly climbed from less than 2% to over 18% with the addition of your S4 before you switched it off prematurely

It would have been a more accurate test of your S4 with p2pool if you had kept it running for the full 10 minutes - but as we can clearly see by the graph, the S4 does
not work efficiently with p2pool, as you wrongly stated earlier with your 1 minute screen. It also didn't get anywhere near 2Th.
I was under the impression that Bitmain was doing some major development with their hardware & it's problem with p2pool - but this miner seems to be a bigger version of the poorly performing S2 with p2pool I'm afraid.
Can you tell me what settings you were using in cgminer?
IYF.