This is where you are wrong.  Somebody, who was a relatively unknown poster, posted a question with no screenshot attached, no mining address attached, no definite dates given... no PROOF at all.  It was just a simple question.  A simple answer was provided.  The OP accepted the answer and moved on.

The whole thing might have been 100% fictional.  "Something unexpected happened" might not have happened at all!  Therefore, there is no demonstration of an actual problem with Eligius.  If 3 or 4 other people piped up with the same problem, ok, we might have a problem on our hands.  If the OP provides more evidence, ok, we might have a problem on our hands.  If a simple answer is given, indicating that a simple but rare situation had occurred and that there is no actual problem, and the OP accepts that simple answer and moves on, then the problem did not exist.

You can't give credence to every little thing and use it to determine that there is a problem.  "TROLL X SAYS Y, THEREFORE Y IS TRUE AND ELIGIUS IS GOING DOWN THE TOILET" is not a valid thread of logic.  (Not saying the OP was a troll.  Just that he *could* have been, and without proof one way or the other, or corroboration by others, there is no way to tell.)